Crossbearing · standards comparison
PCI DSS to ISO/IEC 27001
What you can reuse, what to extend and what is new when you add ISO/IEC 27001 to PCI DSS.
Compare another pair
What carries over from PCI DSS to ISO/IEC 27001
Your PCI DSS controls cover a good part of Annex A’s technical ground, but only inside the cardholder data environment, and ISO/IEC 27001 needs what PCI DSS doesn’t ask for: a management system. Expect new work on the ISMS scope and context, an organisation-wide risk assessment and treatment, a Statement of Applicability, objectives, internal audit and management review — and on controls PCI DSS barely touches, such as business continuity, legal requirements and privacy.
Of the 118 clauses and controls ISO/IEC 27001 asks for: 54 to extend and 64 new.
- 54 Extend Keep what you have and add the new standard’s content.
- 64 New Nothing you have covers it: new work.
Do I need to rewrite my policies?
No rewrite, but a re-frame. Your PCI DSS policies are a strong base for ISO/IEC 27001’s topic-specific policies, but they are written for the CDE. Widen them to the whole ISMS scope, and make sure the information security policy comes from top management, frames your security objectives, and commits to meeting requirements and to continual improvement.
The management system, clause by clause
ISO/IEC 27001 is a management-system standard with clauses 4 to 10; PCI DSS isn’t. Each row says what ISO/IEC 27001 asks for, and which parts of PCI DSS already support it.
| Clause | Your PCI DSS | ISO/IEC 27001 asks for | What to do |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4.1 Context | Nothing here | Internal and external issues that affect what the ISMS is meant to achieve — including, since the 2024 amendment, whether climate change is relevant. | New PCI DSS has nothing like this. Analyse the internal and external issues that affect your security, beyond card data, including whether climate change is relevant. |
| 4.2 Interested parties | Nothing here | Who has a stake in information security, what they require, and which of those requirements the ISMS will address. | New Your acquirer and the payment brands are already interested parties. Add the others — customers, regulators, staff, suppliers — and decide which of their requirements the ISMS will address. |
| 4.3 Scope | 12.5 | The boundaries of the ISMS: which parts of the organisation, locations, assets and interfaces it covers. | Extend Your PCI DSS scope helps define the ISMS scope, but they are different things. Decide what the ISMS covers — perhaps far more than the CDE — and document its boundaries and interfaces. |
| 4.4 The management system | Nothing here | An ISMS that is set up, run, maintained and continually improved, with its processes and how they interact. | New Nothing in PCI DSS corresponds: new work for the ISMS. |
| 5.1 Leadership | 12.4 | Top management directs and supports the ISMS: aligned with strategy, built into the business, resourced and communicated. | New Executive responsibility for PCI DSS is a start. ISO/IEC 27001 wants top management to direct the whole ISMS: aligned with strategy, resourced, and built into the business. |
| 5.2 Policy | 12.1 | An information security policy from top management that frames objectives and commits to meeting requirements and improving. | Extend Your security policy carries over. Make sure top management sets it, that it frames objectives, and that it commits to meeting requirements and to continual improvement. |
| 5.3 Roles | 12.1 | Responsibilities and authorities for information security assigned and communicated. | Extend Your PCI DSS roles carry over. Add the responsibility for reporting on how the ISMS performs, and roles for the whole ISMS scope. |
| 6.1.1 Risks and opportunities | Nothing here | Plan how the ISMS addresses the risks and opportunities that come from its context and interested parties. | New Nothing in PCI DSS corresponds: new work for the ISMS. |
| 6.1.2 Risk assessment | 12.3 | A repeatable information security risk assessment: criteria for acceptance and assessment, risk owners, likelihood and consequence, prioritisation. | New Targeted risk analyses are inputs, not a risk assessment. ISO/IEC 27001 needs a repeatable process across the whole scope, with criteria for accepting risk, risk owners, and likelihood and consequence. |
| 6.1.3 Risk treatment | Nothing here | Choose treatments and the controls they need, compare them with Annex A, write a Statement of Applicability (6.1.3 d) and a treatment plan approved by the risk owners. | New PCI DSS sets its controls for you, so there is no treatment choice to record. Choose controls for each risk, compare them with all 93 Annex A controls, and write a Statement of Applicability and a treatment plan. |
| 6.2 Objectives | Nothing here | Measurable information security objectives, with plans for who achieves them, how and by when. | New PCI DSS has no security objectives. Set measurable ones for the ISMS, with plans for who achieves them and by when. |
| 6.3 Planning changes | Nothing here | Changes to the management system are carried out in a planned way. | New Nothing in PCI DSS corresponds: new work for the ISMS. |
| 7.1 Resources | Nothing here | The resources the management system needs are provided. | New Nothing in PCI DSS corresponds: new work for the ISMS. |
| 7.2 Competence | 6.2 | People whose work affects information security are competent, with evidence kept. | New PCI DSS training for developers and incident responders helps. ISO/IEC 27001 wants competence defined for everyone whose work affects security, with evidence kept. |
| 7.3 Awareness | 12.6 | People know the security policy, their part in the ISMS, and what failing to follow it means. | Extend Your awareness programme carries over. Make sure people know the security policy, how they contribute to the ISMS, and what not following it means. |
| 7.4 Communication | Nothing here | What is communicated, when, to whom and how. | New Nothing in PCI DSS corresponds: new work for the ISMS. |
| 7.5 Documented information | 1.12.13.14.15.16.17.18.19.110.111.1 | Documents and records the ISMS needs are created, updated and controlled. | Extend Your PCI DSS documentation carries over. Put it under the ISMS’s document control: approval, versions, distribution and retention. |
| 8.1 Operational control | Nothing here | Processes planned, run and controlled, including outsourced ones, with evidence that they ran as planned. | New Nothing in PCI DSS corresponds: new work for the ISMS. |
| 8.2 Risk assessment in operation | 12.3 | Risk assessments carried out at planned intervals and when significant changes happen. | New Targeted risk analyses help. Run the ISMS risk assessment at planned intervals and when significant changes happen, and keep the results. |
| 8.3 Risk treatment in operation | Nothing here | The risk treatment plan implemented. | New Nothing in PCI DSS corresponds: new work for the ISMS. |
| 9.1 Monitoring and measurement | Nothing here | What is monitored and measured, how and when, and how the results are evaluated. | New Nothing in PCI DSS corresponds: new work for the ISMS. |
| 9.2 Internal audit | 12.4 | Internal audits at planned intervals, by objective auditors, against the standard and the organisation’s own requirements. | New Quarterly reviews by service providers help, but an annual PCI DSS assessment isn’t an internal audit. Set up an audit programme covering the whole ISMS, with objective auditors. |
| 9.3 Management review | Nothing here | Top management reviews the ISMS at planned intervals, with set inputs and recorded decisions. | New PCI DSS has no management review. Have top management review the ISMS at planned intervals, with set inputs and recorded decisions. |
| 10.1 Continual improvement | Nothing here | The ISMS keeps getting more suitable, adequate and effective. | New Nothing in PCI DSS corresponds: new work for the ISMS. |
| 10.2 Nonconformity and corrective action | Nothing here | Nonconformities are corrected, their causes found and removed, and the actions checked. | New Nothing in PCI DSS corresponds: new work for the ISMS. |
Controls: ISO/IEC 27001 Annex A, against PCI DSS v4.0.1 requirements
Each ISO/IEC 27001 Annex A control, with the PCI DSS requirements that support it. PCI DSS controls apply to the cardholder data environment: widen them to the ISMS scope.
| ISO/IEC 27001 control | Supported by your PCI DSS | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Organisational | ||
| 5.1 Security policy set, approved and kept under review |
| Extend Your PCI DSS policies carry over. Widen them to the ISMS scope, and add the topic-specific policies your risks call for that PCI DSS doesn’t ask for. |
| 5.2 Security roles and responsibilities assigned |
| Extend Your PCI DSS roles carry over. Extend them to every part of the ISMS scope. |
| 5.3 Conflicting duties kept apart |
| New Separating development and production duties helps. Look for other conflicting duties across the organisation. |
| 5.4 Managers require staff to follow security policy | No counterpart | New Nothing in PCI DSS v4.0.1 requirements corresponds: new work. |
| 5.5 Contacts with the relevant authorities | No counterpart | New Nothing in PCI DSS v4.0.1 requirements corresponds: new work. |
| 5.6 Links with security forums and specialist groups | No counterpart | New Nothing in PCI DSS v4.0.1 requirements corresponds: new work. |
| 5.7 Threat intelligence gathered and used |
| New Using industry sources for vulnerabilities helps. ISO/IEC 27001 wants threat intelligence gathered, analysed and used more widely. |
| 5.8 Security built into projects | No counterpart | New Nothing in PCI DSS v4.0.1 requirements corresponds: new work. |
| 5.9 Inventory of information and assets, with owners |
| Extend Your inventory of in-scope components carries over. Widen it to all information and assets in the ISMS scope, with owners. |
| 5.10 Rules for acceptable use of information and assets |
| Extend Your acceptable use rules carry over. Widen them to all information and assets, not only end-user technologies. |
| 5.11 Assets handed back when people leave | No counterpart | New Nothing in PCI DSS v4.0.1 requirements corresponds: new work. |
| 5.12 Information classified by sensitivity |
| New Card data handling helps. Set a classification scheme for all information, by confidentiality, integrity and availability needs. |
| 5.13 Information labelled to match its classification | No counterpart | New Nothing in PCI DSS v4.0.1 requirements corresponds: new work. |
| 5.14 Rules for transferring information |
| Extend Rules for card data in transit carry over. Write transfer rules for all information, electronic, physical and verbal. |
| 5.15 Access control rules |
| Extend Your access rules carry over. Widen them to all information and systems in the ISMS scope. |
| 5.16 Identities managed through their life cycle |
| Extend Account management carries over. Apply it to every identity in the ISMS scope. |
| 5.17 Passwords and other secrets managed |
| Extend Password and secret management carries over. Apply it across the ISMS scope. |
| 5.18 Access rights granted, reviewed and removed |
| Extend Access reviews carry over. Apply them to all systems in the ISMS scope, on intervals your risk assessment sets. |
| 5.19 Security in supplier relationships |
| Extend Service provider management carries over. Apply it to every supplier that affects information security, not only those touching card data. |
| 5.20 Security terms in supplier contracts |
| Extend Written agreements carry over. Add security terms to every supplier contract that needs them. |
| 5.21 Security across the ICT supply chain |
| New Service provider checks help. Manage security risks across the ICT supply chain, including the products you buy. |
| 5.22 Supplier services monitored and reviewed |
| Extend Annual checks on service providers carry over. Monitor and review every relevant supplier’s security and service delivery. |
| 5.23 Security for the cloud services you use | No counterpart | New Nothing in PCI DSS v4.0.1 requirements corresponds: new work. |
| 5.24 Incident management planned and prepared |
| Extend Your incident response plan carries over. Widen it to all incidents in the ISMS scope, not only those affecting card data. |
| 5.25 Security events assessed and classified |
| Extend Alert handling helps. Define how security events are assessed and when they become incidents. |
| 5.26 Incidents responded to by procedure |
| Extend Your incident response carries over. Apply the documented procedures to every type of incident. |
| 5.27 Lessons from incidents applied |
| New Updating the plan from lessons learned carries over. Use what incidents teach to strengthen controls across the ISMS. |
| 5.28 Evidence collected and preserved |
| New Incident response helps. Set procedures for collecting and preserving evidence so it can be used in disciplinary or legal action. |
| 5.29 Security kept up during disruption | No counterpart | New Nothing in PCI DSS v4.0.1 requirements corresponds: new work. |
| 5.30 ICT ready for business continuity | No counterpart | New Nothing in PCI DSS v4.0.1 requirements corresponds: new work. |
| 5.31 Legal, regulatory and contractual requirements identified | No counterpart | New Nothing in PCI DSS v4.0.1 requirements corresponds: new work. |
| 5.32 Intellectual property respected | No counterpart | New Nothing in PCI DSS v4.0.1 requirements corresponds: new work. |
| 5.33 Records protected |
| New Log protection and retention help. Protect all records the organisation must keep, by legal, contractual and business need. |
| 5.34 Privacy and personal data protected | No counterpart | New Nothing in PCI DSS v4.0.1 requirements corresponds: new work. |
| 5.35 Independent review of security |
| New Independent penetration testing helps. ISO/IEC 27001 wants independent reviews of the whole approach to information security. |
| 5.36 Compliance with security policies checked |
| Extend Managing PCI DSS compliance helps. Check compliance with all your security policies and standards regularly. |
| 5.37 Operating procedures documented |
| Extend Your PCI DSS procedures carry over. Document the operating procedures for the rest of the ISMS scope. |
| People | ||
| 6.1 Background checks before people join |
| Extend Screening carries over. Apply it to everyone joining, proportionate to the information they’ll access. |
| 6.2 Security duties in terms of employment | No counterpart | New Nothing in PCI DSS v4.0.1 requirements corresponds: new work. |
| 6.3 Security awareness, education and training |
| Extend Your awareness training carries over. Widen it to everyone in the ISMS scope, with role-based training where needed. |
| 6.4 Disciplinary process for policy breaches | No counterpart | New Nothing in PCI DSS v4.0.1 requirements corresponds: new work. |
| 6.5 Duties that continue after people leave or move | No counterpart | New Nothing in PCI DSS v4.0.1 requirements corresponds: new work. |
| 6.6 Confidentiality agreements | No counterpart | New Nothing in PCI DSS v4.0.1 requirements corresponds: new work. |
| 6.7 Remote working secured |
| Extend Controls on devices that reach the CDE help. Set security measures for all remote working. |
| 6.8 Staff report security events | No counterpart | New Nothing in PCI DSS v4.0.1 requirements corresponds: new work. |
| Physical | ||
| 7.1 Secure perimeters |
| Extend CDE physical security carries over. Define perimeters for all areas with information or systems in the ISMS scope. |
| 7.2 Entry controls |
| Extend Entry controls and visitor logs carry over. Apply them to every secure area in the ISMS scope. |
| 7.3 Offices, rooms and facilities secured | No counterpart | New Nothing in PCI DSS v4.0.1 requirements corresponds: new work. |
| 7.4 Premises monitored |
| Extend Monitoring access to sensitive areas carries over. Widen premises monitoring to the ISMS scope. |
| 7.5 Protection from physical and environmental threats | No counterpart | New Nothing in PCI DSS v4.0.1 requirements corresponds: new work. |
| 7.6 Rules for working in secure areas |
| New Visitor escorting helps. Set rules for working in all secure areas. |
| 7.7 Clear desks and locked screens |
| New Re-authentication after 15 minutes idle helps. Set clear desk and clear screen rules for papers, media and unattended devices. |
| 7.8 Equipment sited and protected |
| Extend Protecting card-reading devices helps. Site and protect all equipment in the ISMS scope. |
| 7.9 Assets protected off site |
| New Inspecting devices helps. Protect all assets used off site. |
| 7.10 Storage media handled securely |
| Extend Card data media handling carries over. Apply it to all storage media. |
| 7.11 Power and other utilities protected | No counterpart | New Nothing in PCI DSS v4.0.1 requirements corresponds: new work. |
| 7.12 Cabling protected | No counterpart | New Nothing in PCI DSS v4.0.1 requirements corresponds: new work. |
| 7.13 Equipment maintained | No counterpart | New Nothing in PCI DSS v4.0.1 requirements corresponds: new work. |
| 7.14 Equipment wiped before disposal or reuse |
| Extend Secure destruction carries over. Wipe or destroy all equipment and media before disposal or reuse. |
| Technological | ||
| 8.1 User devices protected |
| Extend Controls on devices that reach the CDE help. Protect every user endpoint in the ISMS scope. |
| 8.2 Privileged access restricted |
| Extend Controls on administrator and system accounts carry over. Restrict and manage privileged access everywhere. |
| 8.3 Access to information restricted |
| Extend Need-to-know access carries over. Restrict access to all information in the ISMS scope. |
| 8.4 Access to source code controlled | No counterpart | New Nothing in PCI DSS v4.0.1 requirements corresponds: new work. |
| 8.5 Secure authentication |
| Extend MFA and strong passwords carry over. Set authentication by the sensitivity of each system. |
| 8.6 Capacity managed | No counterpart | New Nothing in PCI DSS v4.0.1 requirements corresponds: new work. |
| 8.7 Malware protection |
| Extend Anti-malware carries over. Apply it across the ISMS scope, with user awareness. |
| 8.8 Technical vulnerabilities managed |
| Extend Scanning, patching and penetration testing carry over. Apply them to all systems in scope, at intervals set by risk. |
| 8.9 Configurations managed |
| Extend Configuration standards carry over. Apply them to all hardware, software, services and networks in scope. |
| 8.10 Information deleted when no longer needed |
| Extend Deleting card data past its retention carries over. Delete all information once it is no longer needed. |
| 8.11 Data masking |
| Extend Masking card numbers carries over. Decide where else data masking is needed, such as personal data. |
| 8.12 Data leakage prevented |
| Extend Stopping card numbers being copied helps. Apply data leakage prevention to all sensitive information. |
| 8.13 Backups |
| New Securing backup media helps. Set a backup policy for information, software and systems, and test restores. |
| 8.14 Redundancy for availability | No counterpart | New Nothing in PCI DSS v4.0.1 requirements corresponds: new work. |
| 8.15 Logging |
| Extend Your audit logging carries over. Apply it across the ISMS scope, with retention set by need. |
| 8.16 Monitoring for anomalous behaviour |
| Extend Log review, intrusion detection and change detection carry over. Monitor networks, systems and applications across the ISMS scope. |
| 8.17 Clocks synchronised |
| Extend Time synchronisation carries over. Apply it to all systems in scope. |
| 8.18 Powerful utility programs restricted | No counterpart | New Nothing in PCI DSS v4.0.1 requirements corresponds: new work. |
| 8.19 Software installation on live systems controlled |
| New Change detection helps. Control software installation on all operational systems. |
| 8.20 Networks secured |
| Extend Network security controls carry over. Apply them to all networks in scope. |
| 8.21 Network services secured |
| New Network controls carry over. Set security requirements for all network services, including those from providers. |
| 8.22 Networks segregated |
| Extend Segmentation carries over. Segregate other groups of services, users and systems by risk. |
| 8.23 Web filtering |
| New Anti-phishing helps. Manage access to external websites to reduce exposure to malicious content. |
| 8.24 Cryptography and key management |
| Extend Cryptography and key management carry over. Set rules for using cryptography for all information, not only card data. |
| 8.25 Secure development life cycle |
| Extend Your secure development practices carry over. Apply them to all software development in scope. |
| 8.26 Security requirements for applications |
| Extend Protecting web applications carries over. Set security requirements for every application you develop or acquire. |
| 8.27 Secure architecture and engineering principles |
| New Secure coding practices help. Set secure engineering principles for systems as a whole. |
| 8.28 Secure coding |
| Extend Secure coding carries over. Apply it to all development. |
| 8.29 Security testing before release |
| Extend Code review and penetration testing help. Define security testing for every release. |
| 8.30 Outsourced development overseen |
| New Secure development rules help. Direct, monitor and review all outsourced development. |
| 8.31 Development, test and live environments kept apart |
| Extend Separating test and live environments carries over. Apply it across all development. |
| 8.32 Changes controlled |
| Extend Change control carries over. Apply it to all changes to systems in scope. |
| 8.33 Test data protected |
| Extend Keeping live card numbers out of testing helps. Protect all test data, including personal data. |
| 8.34 Audit testing that protects live systems | No counterpart | New Nothing in PCI DSS v4.0.1 requirements corresponds: new work. |
What to do with each document
The documented information ISO/IEC 27001 requires, and what to do with yours. Tick each one off as you go: the ticks are kept in this browser only.
A route from PCI DSS to ISO/IEC 27001
-
Scope and context
- Decide the ISMS scope: the CDE alone, or the wider organisation
- Analyse context and interested parties beyond the payment brands
-
Leadership and policy
- An information security policy from top management
- Measurable security objectives, and ISMS roles
-
Risk
- Set an organisation-wide risk assessment method, criteria and risk owners
- Use your targeted risk analyses as inputs, then treat the risks
-
Statement of Applicability
- Go through all 93 Annex A controls, citing your PCI DSS controls where they apply
- Widen them to the ISMS scope and add the controls PCI DSS doesn’t cover
-
Run and check
- Operate the ISMS and keep its records
- Internal audit, management review and corrective action
-
Certification
- Choose an accredited certification body
- Plan the stage 1 and stage 2 audits
Certification and audits
- ISO/IEC 27001 is certified by an accredited certification body: a stage 1 and a stage 2 audit, surveillance audits each year, and recertification every three years.
- Your Report on Compliance or Self-Assessment Questionnaire shows controls working in the CDE, but auditors will look for the ISMS records: risk assessment, Statement of Applicability, internal audit and management review.
Common pitfalls
- Scoping the ISMS to the CDE alone, then finding that customers expect the certificate to cover the services they buy.
- Treating the PCI DSS requirements as a Statement of Applicability. The SoA must address all 93 Annex A controls, with a justification for each.
- Expecting targeted risk analyses to serve as the risk assessment. ISO/IEC 27001 needs a repeatable assessment across the whole scope, with criteria and risk owners.
- Forgetting the controls PCI DSS barely touches: business continuity (5.29, 5.30), legal and contractual requirements (5.31), intellectual property (5.32) and privacy (5.34).
PCI DSS and ISO/IEC 27001 at a glance
| Fact | PCI DSS | ISO/IEC 27001 |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Industry standard | Certifiable standard |
| How it applies | Required by contract or programme rules | Voluntary, often required by customers |
| How you show it | Assessed under the scheme’s own rules | Certification by an accredited certification body |
| Where | International | International |
| Covers | Information security, Audit & assurance, Application security | Information security, Risk management, Audit & assurance |
| Issued or enforced by | PCI Security Standards Council (PCI SSC); compliance programmes enforced by payment brands and acquirers | ISO and IEC (joint technical committee ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 27) |
| Current edition or status | PCI DSS v4.0.1 (June 2024) is the active version. Requirements that were future-dated in v4.0 became mandatory on 31 March 2025. | ISO/IEC 27001:2022, amended by ISO/IEC 27001:2022/Amd 1:2024 (climate change considerations). The 2013 edition's certification transition has ended. |
Next steps on MajorCyber™
Sources
- PCI DSS (standard overview) — PCI Security Standards Council
- PCI SSC Document Library (PCI DSS v4.0.1) — PCI Security Standards Council
- ISO/IEC 27001:2022 — Information security management systems — Requirements — International Organization for Standardization (ISO)
Open questions
- We found no mapping between PCI DSS and ISO/IEC 27001 from the PCI SSC, so these links are MajorCyber™’s analysis, made at the level of PCI DSS’s 63 second-level requirements. The sub-requirements under each one can go further than the notes say: the standard itself is the authority.
- The appendices (A1 for multi-tenant service providers, A2 for early TLS on POS POI terminals, A3 for designated entities) aren’t mapped here.
An educational comparison, researched and drafted with AI assistance. A mapping shows where work you have already done supports a requirement; it never means the requirement is met. Your certification body decides what conforms. No standard’s text is reproduced: buy the standards from ISO or your national standards body.